Post Trip Reflection: Visiting the Baseball Hall of Fame

By Jake Fernung

It is now Sunday and we are all back from Cooperstown. The trip is officially over. Wednesday through Saturday many memories were shared, and being able to visit Baseball’s Hall of Fame was nothing short of an awesome experience, completely living up to and exceeding expectations. The Hall of Fame itself was definitely a sight to see. I was amazed at all the artifacts dating back to before baseball was known as baseball. It was also fun to see more recent artifacts and to re-live moments of my childhood. Listening to librarian Jim Gates and curator Erik Strohl was so cool, as both were incredibly knowledgeable and shared inside information and individual memories.


The location of the Hall of Fame is very interesting, being in the middle of Cooperstown, which is essentially in the middle of nowhere. The small downtown area didn’t take long to see, but the numerous baseball shops, each one somehow unique, were fun to explore. I bought some baseball cards and a hat as souvenirs. The food was decent but overpriced (as is much of the stuff in Cooperstown), and I ate a lot of pizza and cheeseburgers. After our days were done downtown, returning to the hotel and then proceeding to watch postseason baseball as a group was also a good time. Overall, the trip was a great time with a great group of people. I learned and saw a lot, and had a ton of fun doing it. I hope to return someday to the Baseball Hall of Fame, and be able to look back and remember all the enjoyment I had on this trip.

boy with bat

Post Trip Reflection on visiting the Baseball Hall of Fame

By Tony Eley

What an amazing experience! The trip to Cooperstown as part of the Baseball and American Identity Freshman Tutorial was one of the most enjoyable experiences of my college career so far. The museum was very interesting and held a lot of fascinating artifacts and history. I enjoyed all the aspects of the museum and all the presentations while we were there. The presentation of the artifacts was one of the most interesting things we did while we were there. Being able to see the “muffin book” and Jackie Robinson`s stat sheet from his rookie year was very interesting and showed the great history behind the sport. Also, the presentation by the head curator, and how he talked about how planning out and putting together exhibits, was also very intriguing.


The town itself was also beautiful and fun to explore. Going in the fall might have made it a little chillier than we would have liked, but the cold was a small price to pay for the beautiful fall scenery of the town. The town seemed to resemble a time of early America, and how majestic of a time it was. The shops were also very fun to visit and had lots of souvenirs for us to buy. I think I can also speak for everyone when saying how comfortable the hotel rooms were also. They were a nice switch up from either a dorm room or a cold dorm. All in all, the trip was fantastic, and will be something I won’t soon forget. I want to thank everyone who made this trip possible and allowing us to have such an unforgettable experience.

The Village of Cooperstown: Baseball with a View

By Kevin O’Donnell

The city of Cooperstown is a lot different than one might expect when they first hear that the Baseball Hall of Fame is there. I always expected it to be a large, lively town that had so much to do for all ages. But to my surprise, it was a small, quaint town that looked as if it were just any other town in the United States. The only thing that sets this small town apart, besides the Hall of Fame, is the abundance of baseball memorabilia shops on the main street of the town (which is indeed called Main Street). These shops lead you to the Baseball Hall of Fame. However, the memorabilia shops aren’t the only signature of this town; the town also has an unbelievable view.

The town itself sits up on a hill that overlooks beautiful Lake Otsego. Not only does it look over this beautiful lake, but it also is surrounded by the tree-lined hills of upstate New York. This is most prominent during the fall when you see the changing colors of each tree. This beautiful town is a tremendous place to have such an amazing spectacle for America’s greatest pastime.

O'Donnell Lake

Village of Cooperstown

By Clayton Corey ‘19

Today I and some classmates walked down the main street of Cooperstown and looked through shops and restaurants. It is a very nice town. It definitely has a small town feeling to it as you walk down the street. One lady in a store even said her dad saw us and said, “Hey look there are aroundtown1college students here this weekend!” Everybody knows everybody here in the town. It is just like how it is portrayed in movies with small towns like Radio.

As we walked from shop to shop we realized everybody in this town loves baseball. Store owners were reminiscing about the game that took place last night. We had conversations with some of them about plays from the game. They are all very friendly people and understand that we are all in awe of the memorabilia that is here to look at. All of the shops are very nice as they all have the typical baseball memorabilia such as hats, shirts, jerseys, trading cards and baseballs, but every shop is also unique in its own way. Every shop has different baseballs signed by players, signed jerseys or signed pictures. Each artifact is unique and most are very expensive.

There is also a beautiful lake right down the street from the Hall of Fame. Outside of the main street with the shops it is mostly residential housing. The main street has a weird feature that all of us are baffled by. There is a flag post in the middle of the street that is in the middle of an intersection. It is very odd but it makes for a great centerpiece for a picture of the street.

Andre and Sodipe on Biko

Derek Andre ’16 -  Throughout this semester, with nearly all of our engagements with South African literature, a common theme of madness has permeated our readings. We’ve dealt with a woman descending into a schizophrenic mania, a daughter committing patricide and acquiring a strange form of Stockholm Syndrome for her rapist, and general disjointedness to the prose that indicates that this theme of hysteria may run deeper than just these two examples. For the first few weeks of the course, I struggled to understand where this psychosis stemmed from; of course it’s understandable that the insanity could be driven by the authors’ individual reactions to the Apartheid regime, but to see such a pervasiveness caught me off guard initially. After reading Steve Biko, however, this ubiquity makes much more sense. In his book I Write What I Like, Biko continually returns to this concept of Black Consciousness. While it’s difficult to put a precise definition on the idea, Black Consciousness is, essentially, the perspective of the black individual, formed by the circumstances in which black people often find themselves. Often, this consciousness involves an inferiority complex and Biko explicitly states that being ‘black’ is a matter of thought, not one of skin color. Ultimately, Biko contends, the goal of the Black Consciousness movement is to create an environment where black people can view themselves as independent and important beings. He says “what Black Consciousness seeks to do is to produce at the output end of the process real black people who do not regard themselves as appendages to white society.” With this concept of a specific Black Consciousness in mind, it seems, at least in my opinion, that much of the insanity we have seen in our other readings is emblematic of the characters’ internal conflicts between seeing themselves as unnecessary attachments to the white, male hegemonic society and seeing themselves as sovereign beings capable of asserting their own place in that society. While it would be convenient for the characters to simply be able to achieve this new level of consciousness without descending into a sort of madness, I think this descent is representative of the difficulty of ascending beyond the hegemony. Biko even seems to have these signs of conflict in his own writings; however, he also seems to have moved beyond the desire to ‘fit in’ for the most part. In sum, I feel that Steve Biko’s writings speak to something significant about not only the black consciousness, but also the South African consciousness.


Immanuel Mitchell-Sodipe ’18 - When reading Steve Biko’s I Write What I Like, I couldn’t help but draw connections between his philosophy of Black Consciousness and my own personal experience in a modern day liberation struggle — the Black Lives Matter Movement. Black Consciousness, in sum, is the view that black people’s liberation is connected deeply to their appreciation of blackness. In fact, that it was key to their liberation. This philosophy influenced some famous names such as Malcolm X, Charles Hamilton, Kwame Ture (Stokely Carmichael) who later developed it into the philosophy of Black Power. This past summer, I attended a conference in Cleveland, OH called the Movement for Black Lives (M4BL). It was like any other conference but instead it was specifically tailored for Black activists, organizers, and Black people. One of the prevailing themes of that conference was the notion that our liberation was tied directly to recognizing and appreciating our blackness. Not only were there workshops on policy formation and direct action training (items that one would expect at a conference tailored for organizers) but also there were workshops that were explicitly tailored to the history of Black arts, Black literature, and things of that nature. One gripe I do have with Biko’s analysis was that he didn’t include a space for queer folks – but I imagine one must consider the times in which he was writing. M4BL did, however, and I think it is necessary to include such a space — a space for queer folks, women, and poor folks — in any analysis for Black liberation. For the liberation of Black people (abroad and domestically) must include a space for the liberation of the most marginalized in that group.

Hall of Fame Immersion Recap Day 2

By Ryan Reeder ‘19

Today was a cold and rainy day in Cooperstown, which was our second day visiting the Baseball Hall of Fame. As soon as we arrived Stephanie Hazzard, Director of Education, talked to us about how the Baseball Hall of Fame educates young students about science and other subjects by using baseball. She also mentioned to the class the internship program that the Hall of Fame offers over the summer. After this the class split up in half; some went to do archival research in the Giamatti Center and the other half went to take pictures of their exhibits or tour the town. I was part of the research group, so I went to the Giamatti Center where my player file full of Kenny Lofton articles awaited me. Kenny Lofton is my Indiana baseball player that I chose to write about for my assignment. Following this extensive research the group then went to go eat lunch. Getting back from lunch the whole class met back together for a session with Erik Strohl, Vice President of exhibitions and collection. Mr. Strohl told the class about how the exhibits in the museum were formed. He then answered a lot of questions from the class of why the museum illustrated some exhibits in a particular way. After the meeting the class went their own ways. Students had the options of either finishing their archival research, looking through the museum more, or walking around Cooperstown. I went to the museum store and to other baseball stores around town. At the stores I looked at the baseball cards and memorabilia, making me feel like a kid again. Later, we all met up again and ended our day in Cooperstown with a class dinner.

Meeting Erik Strohl

By Alex Rudicel ‘19

Our meeting with Mr. Erik Strohl, the Hall of Fame’s Vice President of Exhibitions and Collections, was very enlightening. We began by discussing the type of stuff we study in class and how we go about our discussions over such topics as PEDs or Pete Rose and many others. He then proceededErikStrohl to tell us a little about himself—how he began as an intern for the HOF, much like the many other workers we have talked to—and how his job works. Personally, I was very excited about how he detailed the new exhibit on contemporary baseball that will open in November. For the first time, the HOF is going to directly discuss such topics as Performance Enhancing Drugs and Pete Rose in detail instead of essentially ignoring or barely discussing them. The exhibit will also address the relationship of baseball and 9/11 as well as the effects of technology on the game. This exhibit is potentially controversial since it has the might upset some in baseball (like Barry Bonds who is named for being associated with PEDs although he never failed a test). I wish I could go back to the museum to see this exhibit since it will be very interesting to see how the HOF presents these topics to the public, but I know I won’t be back anytime soon! Our meeting with Mr. Strohl was very insightful and overall made for a better experience at the museum.

Researching Oscar Charleston

By Andrew Tandy ‘19

Visiting the archives today was an eye opening experience that allowed me to look into the lives of sports historians, curious fans, and students like myself. I was astonished at how much care the Hall of Fame has taken to preserve these pieces of baseball history. They went to great lengths to Charleston Oscar Plaque 14_0make sure that the artifacts weren’t damaged by controlling the temperature of the room, and asking the viewers of the artifacts to wear white gloves, as well as a standard no eating or drinking policy. I was in awe at just how extensive the archives were when I noticed a man reading the sports newspapers from the years 1947-1966. In my own research on Negro League star Oscar Charleston, who was from Indianapolis, I found the sources that were pulled for me to be very helpful and full of useful information. The player file that they have for each player provides different looks at that player and stats that give you a broader sense of who the player was. I thought the experience of archival research was a little ritualistic in a sense that the whole process was like going in to see the sacred scrolls. We were the religious patrons and the archives were held to the same level of treatment as the Ten Commandments. All in all visiting the archives was a surreal experience that brings you closer to baseball enlightenment.

Hall of Fame Plaque Room: Preserving Excellence

By Justin Woodard ‘19

The most fabled room in the Baseball Hall of Fame is the plaque room, which marks enshrinement of all the great legends of baseball history. It is the only room in Cooperstown that does its best to appear grand and all-inspiring with marble pillars, marble flooring, bronze plaques, and first classapproximately a twenty-five foot tall ceiling. The first induction class of 1936 is located on the far wall directly across from the entrance, in a way eternally watching those who enter their hallowed halls. Babe Ruth, Ty Cobb, Christy Mathewson, Honus Wagner, and Walter Johnson are ensuring that their room stays a pure sanctuary, where those who violated the game’s rules are not allowed a plaque and the honor of calling yourself one of the greatest. In the hall you will only find players such as Lou Gehrig, Hank Aaron, and Jackie Robinson who succeeded through hard-work, perseverance, and natural talent alone. Joining those great players this year were Randy Johnson, Pedro Martinez, John Smoltz, and Craig Biggio, who all embody the great values of hard-work, perseverance, class, and natural talent.

In addition to the plaques of the legendary baseball players there are two sculptures of Hall of Famers Babe Ruth and Ted Williams, constructed RuthandWilliams2in 1984 and 1985. These sculptures were constructed from a single piece of laminated basswood without any other materials. The detail in these two pieces of art is extraordinary as everything is recreated in the sculptures, from wrinkles in the jersey to the pupils in the eyes of both players. I was very impressed by the amount of detail and the overall dedication to excellence that is presented in the plaque room. The plaque room was a great way to demonstrate how the positive values of hard-work and dedication are represented in the many great ballplayers throughout the game’s history.

Frye and Cramer on Biko

Nick Frye ’16 – In Steve Biko’s I Write What I Like, there is a chapter labeled Black Souls in White Skins? that deals with the issues of whites helping the African movements in South Africa.  Biko labels these whites “the liberals”.  The liberals, in the context of achieving equality for Africans in South Africa, are doing more harm than good, according to Biko.  This is because the white liberals are trying to live in two separate worlds.  On one hand, they are trying to acquire more rights for the African community and, on the other hand, they are trying to save face with the white population by not overstepping their bounds.  Biko claims that these liberals cannot have the best of both of these worlds and says that even though they are trying to help Africans, they are still able to use their white privilege.  The use of their white privilege shows that they are truly not able to understand the hardships that the African community is facing.  Biko states that these white liberals should not concern themselves with helping the Africans directly with their movements, rather, Africans should lead their own movements so they can truly reach their desired goals and not assimilate into what the whites want them to. Whites should address the problems of white racism and privilege amongst the white population. In the times we live in within the United States we are still seeing racial discrimination.  There are many people fighting so that this discrimination can truly end.  Many whites are aiding these issues by joining campaigns and movements.  It is good that they are trying to end discrimination, but the white community is still unable to understand fully what is exactly going on.  They will not know the true struggles that some African Americans have to face on a daily basis and they, like the liberals that Biko talked about, can use their white privilege whenever problems arise for them.  They can still do well for these movements by educating other whites, but they cannot possibly lead these movements for they will not truly understand the struggle.  This is my interpretation of how Biko would see modern day Americans struggle with racial discrimination.

Ben Cramer ’17 - Throughout his life as an activist in apartheid South Africa, Steven Biko produced a substantial body of essays on the social issues that plagued his life. He wrote quite strongly about the police in South Africa and the environment of fear they created, and unfortunately those writings are still relevant today. “One frequently hears people say of someone who has just been arrested or banned – ‘there is no smoke without fire’ or if the guy was outspoken – ‘he asked for it, I am not surprised’. In a sense this is almost defying the security police; they cannot be wrong.” All too often in the last few years while police brutality has become more of a national conversation in the United States, African American men and women are consistently put on trial for their own deaths at the hands of white police officers. Biko’s writings become more and more relevant. It is agonizing to see the public readily accept that police officers are telling the truth about the events that led up to a shooting. Enough people doubt the narrative now, at least, that there is a push for body cameras on police officers, which is one advantage that we have over the 60s and 70s. Advancing technology is letting us hold everyone more accountable, and while that does nothing to bring back those who were brutalized, these advances should help to bring justice in the future, and eventually end the need to bring justice at all.